26-Man Roster Analysis


We’re through the first full month of the 2024 season, so let’s dive into the Mariners’ roster.
When the 2024 season began, my evaluation of the Seattle Mariners was tentative: More upside than any roster under Jerry Dipoto, but more risk than the previous two teams. The results have shown more of the latter than the former.

ROTATION
Luis Castillo, RH
Castillo struggled in his first three outings, allowing four earned runs and 25 total hits in 15.2 innings despite a shiny 18-2 K/BB ratio. It was simply too much plate, particularly with runners on base, and even more specifically with left-handed batters.

Since, however, Castillo has been more consistent with his fastball location, has executed the slider with two strikes, and his changeup has given him some play versus left-handed batters and, voila!, he’s back.

Overall, the Mariners’ Opening Day starter is throwing more four-seamers and sliders at the cost of his changeup and two-seamer, but his usage has bounced around, depending on the outing. But the slider whiff rate is up 6% over 2023 and I think that may be Castillo’s most important pitch, at least when it comes to taking a half step forward from a year ago in terms of consistency.

The two-seamer has been wrecked this season, though it’s a small sample and I expect it to improve moving forward.

Everything Castillo throws is firm, so movement and location are crucial to his success, but he’s a control-over-command power arm, so expecting a bumpless ride through September isn’t a wise gamble.

George Kirby, RH
Kirby’s fastballs, plural, have been insanely effective, and combined he uses them 63% of the time. Opponents are batting .143 off the two-seamer and just .227 with two extra-base knocks versus his four-seam heater, including a 28.4% whiff rate. The four-seam success is not new, though he may be taking it to a new level this season with more extension.

Where Kirby has improved most in 2024 is the swing-and-miss on his curveball, up to 37.5% for the year. He throws it just 8% of the time and it’s not a pitch he goes to finish off hitters much, but it’s helping him create vertical pitch value, one of the reasons his four-seamer is so deadly.

Kirby’s hard-hit rate of just 30% leads all Mariners starters and is No. 7 in baseball. He’s missing the barrel and what may seem like an unsustainable rate of 6.3%, but he logged a 7.5% mark a year ago, also tops on the club.

Ignore the 3.76 ERA attached to his name, because his 2.08 FIP, 3.10 xFP and 2.84 xERA tell the real story, but the one truly unsustainable number here may be the 4.3% HR/FB rate he’s sporting. A year ago, Sonny Gray led baseball at 5.2%, and no qualified pitcher has posted a rate under 5% since Garrett Richards in 2014. But I wouldn’t expect that performance to stray too far.

 

Jason A. Churchill
Follow Jason

You may also like

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

SPONSORS